Teaching labs with open structural data · Lab 3 of 4

Joint sets and structural domains at Mesa Verde

503 joints from the six quadrangle maps that cover Mesa Verde National Park, all drawn by the same geologist. Pooled, they give a tidy answer. Split up, they give a different one, and students have to decide which to believe.

Level
Intro structural geology, after Lab 1
Time
About 2 hours
Format
Individual, pairs for Part 2
Students need
Strike, and what a joint set is

Every joint in this dataset is vertical, so its strike says everything about its orientation and a rose diagram does the work a stereonet would. Most of them are in the Cliff House Formation, the sandstone the park’s cliff dwellings are built into. The lab turns on a question every field geologist runs into sooner or later: when should you pool your measurements, and when should you split them?

Learning goals

By the end of the lab, students can:

  • pick out joint sets on a rose diagram, by eye and in software
  • split a dataset into structural domains and compare the domains fairly
  • explain how pooling several domains can hide a set that each of them contains

Materials

  • The six Mesa Verde CSV files, one per quadrangle, 503 joints in all (download below)
  • A laptop with Stereogram Pro open in a browser

About the data

In 1999 Mary Griffitts mapped Mesa Verde and its surroundings for the National Park Service, on six 7.5-minute quadrangles at 1:24,000; the Park Service’s Geologic Resources Inventory later combined her maps into one GIS database. Every joint she recorded is marked as vertical, with a strike and no dip. Because one person mapped all six sheets, differences between quadrangles are hard to blame on the mapper.

The map places 374 of the 503 joints in the Cliff House Formation and 74 in the Menefee Formation. The rest fall in the Point Lookout Formation, the Mancos Formation and the Dakota Sandstone, and five plot inside alluvium. Those five are a useful reminder that these locations come from a map, not a GPS: at 1:24,000 a symbol can sit a few tens of meters from the outcrop it describes.

A vertical joint has two equally good strikes. A joint striking 030° is the same joint as one striking 210°. The files keep the strike as mapped, so a few values fall between 180° and 360°; the software folds them back for you, so a joint mapped at 357° plots at 177°.

The six USGS 7.5-minute quadrangles covering Mesa Verde National Park, with the number of joints mapped in eachCortez33 jointsPoint Lookout70 jointsMancos9 jointsWitherill Mesa166 jointsMoccasin Mesa212 jointsTrail Canyon13 joints108°37.5′W108°30′W108°22.5′W108°15′W37°22.5′N37°15′N37°7.5′NN
Figure 1. The six quadrangles, north at the top, with the number of joints mapped on each. Mancos and Trail Canyon, drawn dashed, cover the park’s eastern edge and hold very few joints.

Part 1 All of Mesa Verde 20 min

  1. Import all six CSV files. Each one becomes its own dataset, named by its quadrangle.
  2. Open a rose diagram of Strike with every dataset visible.
  3. In the rose settings, find Sets · all data and choose Auto. Leave Threshold and the other settings at their defaults.

Questions

  1. 1.1How many sets does the software find in all 503 joints? Give the mean strike and number of joints in each, and the percentage that belong to no set.

Part 2 One quadrangle at a time 45 min

Hide every dataset except one, record what the software finds, then move on to the next. Pairs can split the six quadrangles between them and swap results.

Worksheet. Use the software’s default settings for every quadrangle.
QuadrangleJointsSets (mean strikes)% in no set
Cortez33
Point Lookout70
Mancos9
Witherill Mesa166
Moccasin Mesa212
Trail Canyon13

Questions

  1. 2.1Is there a set that shows up in most quadrangles but not in the pooled result from Part 1? Give its range of mean strikes.
  2. 2.2List the mean strike of the northeast-striking set in each quadrangle where it appears. How much does it change from one quadrangle to the next?
  3. 2.3The software reports sets for Mancos and Trail Canyon too. Would you put those sets in a report? What’s the smallest number of joints you’d accept for defining a set, and why?
  4. 2.4Compare the percentage in no set for the pooled data with the quadrangles. What does that tell you?

Part 3 Why did pooling lose a set? 25 min

  1. 3.1Make every dataset visible again. Lower the Threshold slider step by step, all the way to its minimum. Does the missing set appear?
  2. 3.2Using your answers to 2.1 and 2.2, explain what happens to two nearby sets when you add together quadrangles in which they sit at slightly different strikes. A sketch of three overlapping rose diagrams helps.
  3. 3.3All six maps were drawn by the same geologist in the same year. Why does that make the quadrangle-to-quadrangle differences more convincing?
  4. 3.4Moccasin Mesa is the biggest quadrangle, and it still leaves a lot of joints in no set. Suggest one way to split it further, predict what you’ll see, then try it using the latitude or longitude columns.

Part 4 A domain map 20 min

On a copy of Figure 1, draw a short line through the center of each quadrangle for every set the software found there, oriented at the set’s mean strike. Leave Mancos and Trail Canyon blank or mark them as too few to call. Then write a paragraph answering this: are the joints at Mesa Verde one population, or several domains? Use at least two numbers from Parts 1 and 2 as evidence.

mesa-verde-joints (6 files)

503 joints · 42 kB in total · ID, strike, dip, latitude, longitude, quadrangle, map unit. From NPS DataStore reference 2298770.

Download
For instructors and TAs

Request the answer key

We don’t publish the answers, so students can’t find them. The instructor pack has:

  • worked answers to every question, including the completed Part 2 worksheet
  • the software’s rose diagram for every quadrangle and for the pooled data
  • a tested answer to question 3.4, and the mistakes students usually make

Email us from your institutional address with your name, your course and the lab you’re teaching.

info@sigmageoscience.com Subject: Answer key request, Lab 3

Original dataset

Geologic Resources Inventory (GRI) program, 2023. Digital Geologic-GIS Map of Mesa Verde National Park and Vicinity, Colorado, adapted from National Park Service geologic maps and a map report by Mary O. Griffitts (1999): preliminary geologic maps of the Cortez, Mancos, Moccasin Mesa, Point Lookout, Trail Canyon and Witherill Mesa quadrangles. National Park Service Geologic Resources Inventory program, Lakewood, Colorado.

Available from
NPS DataStore reference 2298770: irma.nps.gov/DataStore/Reference/Profile/2298770. Free, and no account is needed.
Layer used
MEVE_Geologic_Attitude_Observation_Localities, rows whose feature type names joints (all 503 are vertical).
Terms of use
U.S. federal government data, public domain. Cite the GRI product and Griffitts’s source maps if you republish it.
Version used
Issued April 6, 2023.
How our CSVs differ
Joints only, split into one file per source quadrangle, coordinates reprojected to WGS 84 decimal degrees, and map unit attached by point-in-polygon join against the map’s unit layer. No orientation was altered.

Teaching labs with open structural data

  1. 1 Joints in the granite Joshua Tree
  2. 2 The fold axis of the Weissenstein Swiss Jura
  3. 3 Joint sets and structural domains Mesa Verde · You are here
  4. 4 Fault kinematics Blythe